DRM-free MP3 downloads from Amazon

Two years after I first laid out my plea to be able to download music the way I wanted, Amazon have pretty much come through. My canonical test song whenever someone announces a new music service is “Feelin’ Good” by Nina Simone, and here it is on Amazon.com. So, let’s test this service against my list of requirements.

  • I can download one track, instead of a whole album; I don’t want ten Nina Simone songs, I just want the one I’m looking for - PASS
  • No DRM. None. I don’t mind what the format is, if there’s no DRM, as long as it can be played on Linux (which is pretty much everything). Bonus points for oggs. Half a bonus point for just plain mp3. - PASS
  • A track costs a pound or less. I’m not paying more than a quid for one song. - PASS (99c is about 50p)
  • I feel comfortable putting my credit card number into the site. This means, in practice, that if it’s called something like mp3downloads.haxx0r.ru, I am not interested. - PASS
  • I can just buy a song by putting my credit card number in and getting it for download. I don’t need to sign up for an account, give them all my details, none of that. - FAIL
  • My music tastes aren’t very eclectic, so I’d expect the service to carry most of what I’d want to listen to. This means that a service for one label alone isn’t really what I want. I don’t want to discover new music with this; I want to get the stuff I already know about and want to listen to. - PASS
  • I’ll get, probably, about five songs a year. So a subscription service is out, especially since with most of them your music stops working when you unsubscribe. - PASS

So it only fails on one thing: you need to sign up for an account. However, I already have an Amazon account. This is still technically a failure — because my desire for no signup was not only for my own benefit but because I didn’t want it to be a powerplay by some firm who would then spam everyone who bought mp3s until the end of time — but largely people already have Amazon accounts and Amazon have shown themselves (in my experience) to be reasonable citizens in this regard. I don’t receive lots of spam or unsolicited “recommendations” from them, and (from a web, if not open source perspective) I think the Amazon Web Services are a Good Thing. So although that’s a fail I’m prepared to let it slide. Well done Amazon, I say. I suspect that it’s only tracks from some record companies, or some labels, or some other criterion that I don’t care about, but since my test track appears there they must have at least some of the music I like. Now I get to start buying mp3s. Update: dammit, it requires a US billing address. Obviously I could lie about that, but if I was happy to lie then I’d just google for the mp3. So it’s presumably US-only at this point. Anyone got any contacts at Amazon who could give me an indication as to when or whether it’s being rolled out to other countries?

I'm currently available for hire, to help you plan, architect, and build new systems, and for technical writing and articles. You can take a look at some projects I've worked on and some of my writing. If you'd like to talk about your upcoming project, do get in touch.

More in the discussion (powered by webmentions)

  • (no mentions, yet.)